The artificial intelligence investment boom is creating a potential complication for thematic ETFs. As fund managers broaden their definition of AI opportunities, investors may be getting exposure to businesses that have little connection to the industries suggested by an ETF's name.
The Tema Photonics & Optical ETF
Anthropic's blockbuster stock market debut on Thursday has brought that investment into focus. But the bigger issue is what it reveals about the growing disconnect between thematic ETF labels and actual portfolio exposure.
What Does Anthropic Have to Do with Photonics?
LAZR disclosed its Anthropic exposure on July 21, when the privately held company was valued at just under $1 trillion. At the time, Anthropic represented 12.06% of the fund's net assets.
Tema argued that Anthropic complemented the fund's broader AI infrastructure thesis. However, the distinction between infrastructure and applications matters.
Photonics and optical technologies enable high-speed data transmission between chips, servers and data centers. Anthropic, by contrast, develops AI models and products. Both belong to the AI ecosystem, but their businesses have different revenue drivers, competitive dynamics and investment risks.
This exposes a potential blind spot in thematic investing. Investors buying a photonics-focused ETF might expect exposure to optical components, networking technologies and hardware suppliers. But a substantial allocation to an AI model developer introduces an entirely different dimension to the portfolio.
The issue extends beyond one fund. AI investment now spans semiconductors, data centers, cloud computing, foundation models and software applications. As these segments become increasingly interconnected, ETF managers have greater scope to interpret their investment themes broadly.
Consequently, two funds marketed around AI could offer very different exposures, while funds with seemingly distinct investment mandates could end up holding similar companies.
Private AI Holdings Add Complexity
Thematic flexibility is not the only concern. Private-company investments create additional portfolio construction challenges.
Unlike publicly traded stocks, private holdings cannot necessarily be increased whenever fresh money enters an ETF. LAZR's Anthropic weighting had fallen to 6.8% by Wednesday, ahead of the IPO, from double-digit levels previously. Inflows expanded the fund's assets without a corresponding increase in its Anthropic position.
The fund also accesses Anthropic through a special-purpose vehicle (SPV), rather than owning its shares directly. Such structures introduce additional valuation, liquidity and investment-terms considerations.
SpaceX Offers a Precedent
The Tema Space Innovators ETF
The experience highlights the appeal of private-company exposure in thematic ETFs, particularly around anticipated IPOs, but also the difficulty of sustaining investor interest.
As AI investment spreads across chips, optical networking, data centers and foundation models, the boundaries between thematic ETFs are becoming less distinct.
For investors, the risk is assuming that a fund's name tells the whole story. Its actual holdings, position sizes and investment structures may reveal a considerably broader investment strategy.
